GameSpot
- Rated 5.9/10 by Ron Dulin. "What begins as an interesting tale of conspiracy and murder ends up a confused and confusing gore fest of the not-so-supernatural."
- http://www.gamespot.com/pc/adventure/blackdahlia/

Quandary
- "Black Dahlia really is an adventurer's as well as a puzzle lover's dream." By Rosemary Young.
- http://www.quandaryland.com/jsp/dispArticle.jsp?index=219

Brass Lantern
- "It may not end up on my top ten list, but there are enough good moments in the game to make an easy "thumbs up" call, and I have no intentions of selling it anytime soon." By Murray Peterson.
- http://brasslantern.org/reviews/graphic/bdahliapeterson.html

Just Adventure +
- Rated C. "With a bit more attention to the adventure side of the game, and a less dismal conclusion, this could have been a superior product. As it is, anyone who plays Black Dahlia should be prepared for an uneven ride."
- http://www.justadventure.com/reviews/Black_Dahlia/BlackDahliaScorpia.shtm

PIB Review
- "I'd highly recommend the game for atmosphere and the plot. I found it quite compelling."
- http://www.pibweb.com/review/blackd.html